BOOK IT!: The Man Who Loved Books Too Much

The Man Who Loved Books Too Much by Allison Hoover Bartlett, is a fascinating "Already-Know-Who-Dunnit-but-How-and-Why?" thriller that adds a dimension and interest in all of us who love books because it is real. The main protagonists are Ken Sanders, the self-professed "Bibliodick" (bookstore owner turned detective) and John Gilkey, the "man who loved books too much."

Sanders, in his role in security with the Antiquarian Booksellers Association, brought the profession into the 20th century in terms of security, and communication, particularly when it comes to an area that happens all too often, the removal of books by "less than acceptable means" (at least from the thief's standpoint, instead of "stealing", which is the view from this book). Unfortunately success on catching said thieves are not very successful, but it is improving, though in John Gilkey's case, no matter what is done, he will continue to acquire books.

This unique study of Gilkey, demonstrates that age-old saying, "does the ends justify the means?" In Gilkey's case, he would argue yes, and even continue to justify it, by showing his right to own these books, thus allowing him the prestige of others that he feel waste this opportunity. That he uses credit-card scams usually from a department store he had worked, to order over the phone, after scouting the locations, researching extensively, and then carrying out the deed, is acceptable to him, by whatever means to acquire the book.

Perhaps what makes this book so mesmorizing, is that he carries out this activity without a conscience, doing what each of us do (though not to his level)- wanting things we can't have or couldn't afford, but he does something about it. As we lust for that certain book, or (fill in the blank), he accomplishes the end, through whatever means neccessary. The book sets the stage with it's discussion of other famous bibliophiles (those who love books), and bibliomaniacs (those who love them too much), as well as the industry itself.

While I would have liked hearing more about the trade, the books, and the desires each of us have towards books (if anything to justify in us, that we are not alone in this endeavor - while that is briefly covered throughout various parts of the book, it could have developed into an even more significant backdrop)-the detective-thief analysis is fascinating, and effective. Through it's description and handling, I've actually had trouble labeling Gilkey a crook, or criminal, even though that's what he is, and he's even served time for it (actually many times). Perhaps it's because I am fascinated, maybe even in awe of his passion, as he wanted to own the books, not to sell, but to physically hold them (though, in many cases, not even read them): in his case, the Modern Library's top 100 novels of all time, though first editions of all kinds fit the bill nicely (which he never paid out of his own money). And while I would never go to his measures of owning a book, I can almost understand, though never accept, his desire, though I'm sure if we were truly honest, we have all thought of it - and realize that it could be met, for all of us, being just a bookstore, or phone call away. Recommended Highly!!!